The tribunal dismissed all claims because the dismissal was fair (within the range of reasonable responses) and there was no evidence that the claimant's disability, race, or protected acts influenced the decision to dismiss or any other treatment.
Legal Issues (3)
Unfair dismissal – range of reasonable responses
misconduct dismissal
Burchell test. Disability discrimination – section 15 EqA (unfavourable treatment arising from disability). Race discrimination – direct discrimination and comparators. Victimisation – protected acts (previous tribunal claim and complaint about colleague). Procedural fairness of investigation and appeal.
All claims of unfair dismissal and disability discrimination failed and were dismissed as the tribunal found the dismissal was fair and proportionate, and the respondent had acted reasonably.
Legal Issues (3)
Whether the dismissal was for a potentially fair reason (capability)
whether the respondent acted reasonably in dismissing
and whether the dismissal amounted to discrimination arising from disability or a failure to make reasonable adjustments.