All claims were finally dismissed: the earlier claims (unauthorised deduction of wages, breach of contract) were struck out for lack of jurisdiction, and the later claims (unfair dismissal, wrongful dismissal) were dismissed on the merits.
Legal Issues (3)
Jurisdiction for out-of-time claims
erroneous legal advice and the Dedman principle
merits of unfair dismissal and wrongful dismissal claims.
Both claims were dismissed on the merits because the employer's actions were within the band of reasonable responses and the statutory conditions for a redundancy payment were not met.
Legal Issues (2)
Whether the dismissal was unfair under section 94 of the Employment Rights Act 1996
and whether the employer failed to pay a redundancy payment under section 135 of that Act. The key legal points were the band of reasonable responses test for unfair dismissal and the application of sections 141(2) and (3)(b) regarding redundancy payments.
The tribunal found that the claim for unauthorised deduction of wages succeeded, but all other claims (constructive unfair dismissal, discrimination, harassment, victimisation, whistleblowing) failed on liability.
Legal Issues (11)
Key legal points include: whether the claimant was constructively unfairly dismissed
whether there was direct/indirect discrimination
discrimination arising from disability
failure to make reasonable adjustments
harassment
victimisation
or detriment for health and safety disclosures
whether the respondent was entitled to place the claimant on sick pay during medical suspension
and whether the unauthorised deduction claim succeeded. The tribunal found that the respondent was not entitled to treat the claimant as falling within scenario 1 (unwell) for sick pay purposes
and that the claimant should have been on full pay during suspension
leading to a successful unauthorised deduction claim.
The claimant won on all three claims: unfair dismissal, breach of contract (notice pay), and failure to provide written statement.
Legal Issues (1)
Unfair dismissal – Polkey reduction (90% chance of fair dismissal if procedure had been followed). Breach of contract – notice pay (admitted). Failure to provide written statement of employment particulars – section 38 Employment Act 2002.
The Tribunal dismissed the direct race discrimination and direct sexual orientation discrimination claims as out of time, but allowed the harassment related to sex claim to proceed by extending the time limit.
Legal Issues (2)
Whether the claims were presented within the applicable time limit
whether it is just and equitable to extend time for each complaint.
The s47B detriment complaint was dismissed as out of time because it was reasonably practicable to present it in time; the s103A unfair dismissal complaint was allowed to proceed because it was not reasonably practicable to present it in time but was presented within a further reasonable period.
Legal Issues (4)
Whether the complaints were presented within the applicable time limit
if not
whether it was reasonably practicable to present them in time and
whether they were presented within a further reasonable period.
The claimants succeeded on all claims: constructive unfair dismissal, statutory redundancy, breach of contract for notice pay and arrears of salary, and unauthorised deduction for holiday pay, with specific monetary awards made.
Legal Issues (5)
Constructive unfair dismissal
entitlement to statutory redundancy payment
breach of contract for notice pay and arrears of salary
The tribunal found that the respondent's investigation and disciplinary process were fair and reasonable, and that no repudiatory breach of contract occurred, so the claim of constructive unfair dismissal was dismissed.
Legal Issues (4)
Whether the respondent's conduct (including the investigation and disciplinary process) amounted to a repudiatory breach of the implied term of mutual trust and confidence
entitling the claimant to resign and claim constructive dismissal under s.95(1)(c) Employment Rights Act 1996. The tribunal applied the test in Kaur v Leeds Teaching Hospital NHS Trust [2019] ICR 1 and considered whether the alleged breaches
individually or cumulatively
destroyed or seriously damaged the relationship of trust and confidence.
All of the claimant's complaints were dismissed following a hearing where the claimant did not attend.
Legal Issues (1)
The judgment does not specify the legal issues or the nature of the complaints. The only substantive outcome is that the complaints do not succeed and are dismissed.
Both of the claimant's complaints were dismissed on their merits after a full hearing, and the respondent's counterclaim and costs application succeeded.
Legal Issues (4)
Whether the respondent failed to make reasonable adjustments for the claimant's disability
whether the claimant was constructively unfairly dismissed
whether the respondent was entitled to recover sums under the salary sacrifice vehicle scheme
and whether costs should be awarded against the claimant.
All claims were struck out in their entirety due to the claimant's repeated non-compliance with Tribunal orders and failure to actively pursue the claim, making a fair trial impossible.
Legal Issues (3)
Strike-out under Rule 38(1)(c) and (d) of the Employment Tribunal Rules of Procedure 2024 for non-compliance with Tribunal orders and failure to actively pursue the claim. Consideration of the overriding objective
The Tribunal found the claimant was unfairly dismissed, awarded liability on breach of contract and unauthorised deductions, and dismissed the holiday pay claim on withdrawal, with remedy to be determined.
Legal Issues (7)
Whether the claimant was dismissed by conduct (implied dismissal)
the reason for dismissal (some other substantial reason – breakdown in working relationship)
fairness of dismissal (unfair due to lack of procedure)
Polkey reduction (none)
contributory fault (none)
unauthorised deductions (no agreement to defer pay)
wrongful dismissal (no gross misconduct to justify withholding notice).