The respondent failed to present a valid response, and the Legal Officer found the claims well-founded, awarding damages for breach of contract and unpaid holiday pay.
Legal Issues (2)
Breach of contract for failure to pay contractual notice pay
unauthorised deduction from wages for failure to pay accrued holiday pay on termination.
The claimant won on unfair dismissal and unauthorised deductions claims but lost on age and sex discrimination claims, resulting in a split overall outcome.
The Tribunal found the respondent in breach of contract for notice pay and for failing to pay holiday pay, awarding damages and a separate sum for holiday pay.
Legal Issues (3)
Breach of contract in respect of notice entitlement
failure to pay accrued
unused holiday pay upon termination of employment.
Both claims were dismissed: the unauthorised deduction claim was out of time and the sums did not constitute wages, and the breach of contract claim failed because no contractual bonus or binding settlement agreement was established.
Legal Issues (5)
Whether the unauthorised deduction claim was presented in time
whether the sums claimed fell within the definition of 'wages' under section 27 Employment Rights Act 1996
whether there was a contractual entitlement to a bonus
whether a binding settlement agreement was formed
and whether the respondent was in breach of contract.
The claimant succeeded on all claims, with the Tribunal finding unfair dismissal, unlawful deduction of wages, wrongful dismissal, and breach of right to be accompanied, and awarding total compensation of £12,240.88.
Legal Issues (5)
Unfair dismissal under s94 Employment Rights Act 1996
unlawful deduction of wages under s13 ERA 1996 and regulation 13 Working Time Regulations 1998
wrongful dismissal (breach of contract)
breach of right to be accompanied under s10 Employment Relations Act 1999
ACAS Code uplift under s207A Trade Union & Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act 1992.
The Tribunal found that the respondent directly and indirectly discriminated against the claimant on grounds of race by failing to appoint him to the Chair of Division role, and awarded compensation including injury to feelings and financial losses with a 25% uplift for unreasonable failure to follow the ACAS code.
Legal Issues (4)
Direct race discrimination under section 13 Equality Act 2010
indirect race discrimination under section 19 Equality Act 2010
determination of the appropriate pool for comparison in indirect discrimination
application of the ACAS Code of Practice on Disciplinary and Grievance Procedures and uplift for unreasonable failure to comply.
The tribunal found the claimant was dismissed in breach of contract in respect of notice and awarded damages of £1,735.80, so the breach of contract claim succeeded.
Legal Issues (3)
Whether a determination could be made under rule 22 where the respondent failed to present a valid response
whether the dismissal breached the contract in respect of notice
calculation of damages for notice pay using gross weekly pay as Post Employment Notice Pay.
The Tribunal found that the employment of Miss Gratrix, Ms Salduk, Mr Yaghi, and Mr Ochama did not transfer to the Second Respondent, so their claims against the Second Respondent are dismissed; Mrs Skues' employment would have transferred but for her dismissal because of the transfer, so liability transfers to the Second Respondent; Miss Rowe's employment transferred to the Second Respondent, and her wage claims are in time as a series of deductions, but time limits for her breach of contract claim are not yet determined.
Legal Issues (5)
Whether there was a TUPE transfer of part or all of the undertaking from the Third to the Second Respondent
whether dismissals were because of the transfer (Lister v Forth Dry Dock)
time limits for Miss Rowe's claims (unlawful deduction from wages
breach of contract)
application of Regulation 8(7) TUPE regarding insolvency.